Health: Health for Palestine (H4P)

Expanding Healthcare for Refugee Communities

Mission

Health for Palestine (H4P) is a collaborative initiative between Palestinian community centers and international academic health professionals. It is one of 1for3’s Nexus programs, which seek to support the water, food, health, and education needs of Palestinian refugees.

Program: H4P

In 2017 our partners at the Lajee Center alerted us to a growing need to provide a community-based solution for chronically ill residents in two UN-run refugee camps. After iterative discussions with our partners in Palestine & consultations with experts at medical institutions around Boston, Health for Palestine (H4P), a Community Health Worker (CHW) program, was born in January 2018.

Our model of care is based on training young people to be proficient high-touch low-cost care providers. They primarily serve patients with chronic illnesses. Pairs of Community Health Workers (CHWs) visit refugee families at home. This model allows for a high frequency of visits & strong continuity of care with many families being seen dozens of times a year, an impossibility in a physician-only model.

By 2020, H4P supported patients in achieving an average reduction of 1.40 in hemoglobin A1C, a lab test to measure diabetes, which is associated with an approximately 10% reduction in mortality from diabetes over 10 years. This translates to 77% of H4P patients having control of their diabetes as compared to 46% of patients without CHWs. These achievements are consistent with the impact of the best diabetes medications available worldwide. See this article for full details.

Snapshot

We understand that much of health exists beyond simple biomedical pathways. Much of what determines your health & wellness depends on where you live, what stressors you face, & your socio-economic position. In Palestine, there are loud & obvious factors that affect such things. The stress of the occupation, threat of military attacks, presence of walls all can be strong influences on one’s biomedical health.

H4P (Health for Palestine): Community Health Training & Patient-Care Program

  • In 3 refugee camps in the West Bank through Community Health Workers

  • H4P Balata helps Autistic children in the largest camp in the West Bank

  •  H4P has nearly 15,000 home visits conducted since 2018

  • 30 young Palestinians trained as community health workers

  • Partnerships with doctors from Harvard Medical School, Cornell Medical School, Boston Children’s Hospital

  • 14 trained community health workers employed in 3 camps (6 in Aida/Azza; 8 in Balata)

  • 280 patients served in 3 camps (135 in Aida/Azza; 145 in Balata)

  • Ongoing CHW training on community health care, treatment plans for patients, ethics of data collecting & sharing

  • Expansion of training on using nutrition & food production to aid chronic illness healing 

  • Starting culturally aligned well-baby exams in 3 camps with our Pediatric Care Project

  • Increasing diabetes support through increased training, expansion of wellness efforts & easier access to care

     

Community Health Workers (CHWs)

Regular CHW visits provide social support. Over 7 years our trained team has completed 15,000 home visits. CHWs help organize medication lists, create understanding of what conditions patients have, provide emotional & social support, & navigate a confusing healthcare system. In addition, they provide basic instruction & monitoring of diabetes & hypertension, check blood pressure & blood sugar levels, & provide a much-needed bridge to our full staff physicians that work within the Palestinian healthcare system. The overall goal of H4P is to bridge gaps in healthcare, to create an atmosphere of wellness, & to bring health justice to all we work with. We focus on disease that is worsened by stress & trauma, which gives us access to sensitive root causes of illness. Our goal is to name these causes and focus on them, rather than to patch people up & deal only with blood tests & numbers.

Pediatric Care Project

Development Delay Around the World & In Palestine

Our Pediatric Care Project will create a health system to identify refugee children at risk of developmental delay. Early detection of developmental delay improves child & family well-being & contributes to life-long health. Working with physicians from Boston Children’s Hospital & the Happy Child Center, Ramallah, we will serve children in 3 West Bank camps with a total population of 40,000.

The center of this work are checkups, or well child exams. In them we screen for normal growth & development. In these screenings we can look for signs of developmental delay, such as language or speech delay, global delay, or autism. Through the screening process we will increase access for needy families to specialists who can then diagnose formally a condition & work towards long-term support. There is no magic pill or surgery for a developmental delay but rather an interdisciplinary approach towards improving support and life.

We aim to accompany new families who have just had a first child. Achieving a ratio close to 1 CHW to 20 families is our service goal. The project will start in the fall of 2024. We will follow children for 2 years, adding more newborns during the rollout period. Site locations will begin in the UN-run Aida camp & after it move to the UN-run Balata camp as well as to some locations in the Jordan Valley.

Early Childhood Development (ECD) in the West Bank faces care gaps. Only 47% of children experience development activities. There is also limited access to early learning and cognitive development, with only 34% of children aged 3-to-4 attending early childhood care and education. Per a 2015 World Bank report, children had gaps in exposure to developmental activity, specifically in cognitive development, such as reading books, telling stories, and ‘naming, counting, or drawing’. In all activities, including these as well as ‘taking outside’, singing songs, and playing, only 47% of children aged 0-to-4 had experienced 4% percent or more of the developmental activities, with 2% experiencing none. As of 2010, data only existed on these activities for children aged 3-to-4, leaving concern and uncertainty regarding ages 0-to-2.[1]

[1] https://www.worldbank.org/content/dam/Worldbank/document/mna/en/WestBankAndGaza_ecd_ch14.pdf.

The World Health Organization estimated that in 2019, 317 million children & young people were impacted by health conditions that supported the growth of a developmental disability. The diagnosis often came with stigma, marginalization & difficulties in accessing adequate care. Children with developmental delay were found to have a higher premature death rate & as adults experienced significant health problems. Access to a diagnosis & then to care was often found to be fragmented or unavailable. Source.

In Palestine (West Bank and Gaza) research-based data is still growing. One study found that parents of children with developmental delay face small & large barriers to care & support. Another report, by UNICEF State of Palestine, found that children with developmental delay & their care givers face marginalization, stigma, discrimination & challenges related to life under military occupation as barriers to care. Care givers were primarily mothers, usually lacking needed emotional support. They also found it difficult to access care for diagnosed children for a variety of reasons including inadequate transportation, high cost, poor communication & inadequate medical services. Community approaches to reducing stigma, expanding access & reducing barriers to care were thought to be effective towards expanding levels of care.

Diabetes Support

Palestine is a low-to-middle income country. The Impact of diabetes on the population is large & growing as older generations that had low rates of diabetes are passing away. Like in many other Arab countries, changes in dietary habits, physical activity & socio-economic factors are leading to higher rates of diabetes much earlier in lifespans. Since diabetes increases the risk of stroke, heart attacks, kidney disease, vision problems & peripheral vascular disease, the burden of diabetes will have increasing impact on morbidity & mortality in Palestine. The World Bank found that by 2021, 9.3% of the 20-79 year-old population in the West Bank & Gaza had diabetes. Other researchers reported that by 2019, 33% of residents 50 years & older in Gaza & the West Bank had diabetes with more women suffering from it than men. Of diabetes sufferers in Palestine, 17% were found in a further study to have retinopathy (vision difficulties that can lead to blindness) while 23% had multiple microvascular complications caused by diabetes that can affect kidneys, the heart & the brain. Given recent trends, these percentages are expected to continue increasing, suggesting that the health and financial impact of diabetes has not yet been fully apparent within the Palestinian health sector.

To challenge this expanding health crisis, we are developing new levels of care that complement our existing work in treating diabetes. We are increasing our focus on diabetes care that meets the difficult conditions of urban refugee communities living under military violence & apartheid laws. Taking an interdisciplinary & holistic primary care approach, blood pressure control, smoking cessation & cholesterol management will be important. Using community medicine interventions, starting with the Community Health Worker (CHW) model, will support primary care systems. To do this we are undertaking a multi-year program of:

  • Training for new and existing CHWs.

  • Expanding access to care by starting new clinics.

  • Evaluating care based on performance indicators (regular diabetes testing; complex medication management; patient education; smoking cessation; adjacent comorbidities like hypercholesterolemia, obesity & hypertension; community satisfaction; provider knowledge and understanding.

  • Harm reduction.

  • Integrated Behavioral Health.

 

Leadership

  • Bram Wispelwey, MD

    Co-Founder H4P

    Associate Physician, Division of Global Health Equity, Brigham and Women’s HospitalInstructor, Harvard Medical School; Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. He is a Co-founder and Chief Strategist of Health for Palestine. Dr. Wispelwey’s research focuses on structural racism in hospital triage, ethics, community health worker impact, social and political barriers to health, and colonial violence. Before his medical career, Dr. Wispelwey pursued LGBT-rights activism. He is currently an Atlantic Health Equity Fellow.

  • Henry Louis, MD

    H4P International Medical Director

    Family Medicine Resident Physician, University of Massachusetts Medical School. Dr. Louis's responsibilities include supervising all activities related to qualitative and quantitative data collection on program activities. Furthermore, alongside the team of international advisers, Dr. Louis contributes to a diverse array of development efforts including community organizing. His passion for working alongside community members and pursing health equity and social justice have dragged him across the world, from Egypt to Armenia to his current beloved Palestine.

  • Karameh Hawash Kuemmerle, MD

    H4P Balata

    Dr. Karameh is an assistant professor at Harvard Medical School and a pediatric neurologist at Boston Children’s Hospital. She specializes in traumatic brain injury and epilepsy.

    Much of Dr. Karameh’s work takes place in the Brain Injury Center at Boston Children’s Hospital, a multidisciplinary center coordinating care between the Trauma Center, Neurology, Neurosurgery, Sports Medicine, and Neuropsychology.

  • David Scales, MD

    Co-Founder H4P

    Assistant Professor of Medicine, Medicine, Weill Cornell Medical College. He has extensive experience with various NGOs in the region, serving on the board of Questscope and having volunteered to provide medical assistance to Syrian refugees in Jordan. Trained in Sociology and Internal Medicine, his interests center on structural determinants of health, health disparities, and medical communication.

  • Aya Darwish, CHW

    H4P Palestine Director

    Aya has been a community Health worker since 2019. Darwish studied medical laboratory in Bethlehem and continue to study counseling and mental health with a team of local Palestinian and international phycologists.